I’ve been a fan of Louise Penny’s Chief Inspector Gamache mystery novels for years. I was fascinated by the village of Three Pines in Quebec, so small and out of the way that it can’t be found on most maps. The Villages residents – Olivier and Gabri at the Bistro, the off-the-wall poet Ruth Zardo, artist Clara Morrow, Myrna the bookstore owner, all had their stories on how they came to live there. I felt t home with Gamache’s family – his wife Reine-Marie and his grown children. His daughter Annie marries Jean-Guy Beauvoir, Gamache’s second-in-command at the Quebec Surete. And his police team.
From novel to novel, and there are now 20 of them, I’ve followed the characters through personal crises, upheavals, near-death experiences, entanglements in crime, and overall well-done stories. But with No. 18, A World of Curiosities, Penny wallowed personal politics to color the story. I was encouraged with No. 19, The Grey Wolf, because she seemed to be returning to her narrative storyline.
Then came No. 20, the sequel to The Grey Wolf. It’s entitled The Black Wolf.
I have two problems with it.
First, a considerable portion of what was conveyed in The Grey Wolf gets rewritten. What we knew then is not what we find out now. Appearances were deceiving. This happened in a significant way once before in on of Penny’s stories, when a village resident gets caught up in a crime and goes to prison after trial and conviction. In the next novel, what we knew turned out to be untrue, the character is redeemed, and all is well in Three Pines, after all. It happens again with The Black Wolf. It might work as an individual story, but it weakens the overall series. You begin to ask yourself, what else is going to get rewritten?
My more serious problem is that Penny is once again slipping personal politics into the story. She includes the occasional mini-lecture, and the wise characters speak to what’s really right and true. But the heart of the story is the larger part of the problem. Those evil people south of the Canadian border are always up to no good.
 |
| Louise Penny |
What happens is that personal politics overtakes the story. I stopped reading about page 200, just over halfway through. Maybe the story gets better. Maybe the politics goes away. But I decided I didn’t want to find out.
The fact is that I’m tired of politics overtaking everything, and that’s especially true for books I buy expecting to read a good story. I did not pay good money to read Louis Penny displaying her wisdom – or her version of wisdom – on current events and issues. She’s taking pot shots and passing them off as deep insights from her characters. Conservatives are bad. Christians are bad. No one believes in church any more, except perhaps as a place to meet informants (because no one would ever think of going there for any other reason).
If you are of a progressive or leftist persuasion, you might think this is fine. I’m not; neither am I of a far-right persuasion. And I don’t think it’s fine. If you as a mystery writer are going to do this, then you need to slap a warning label on the cover.
So, I bid farewell to Chief Inspector Gamache. I will miss all the pastries and breads dripping in butter at Olivier and Gabri’s bistro. I won’t be reading about crazy Ruth Zardo the poet and her equally crazy duck Rosa. No more support and words of wisdom from Reine-Maries Gamache.
No more anything from characters I’ve thought of as something like friends.
Related:
My review of Kingdom of the Blind.
My review of Glass Houses.
My review of A Great Reckoning.
My review of The Long Way Home.
My review of How the Light Gets In.
My review of The Beautiful Mystery.
My review of The Hangman.
My review of Penny’s A Trick of the Light.
My review of Penny’s A Fatal Grace.
My review of Penny’s Still Life.
My review of Penny’s The Cruelest Month.
My review of Penny’s A Rule Against Murder.
My review of The Brutal Telling.
My review of Penny’s Bury Your Dead.
My review of A Better Man.
My review of All the Devils Are Here.
My review of The Madness of Crowds.
My review of A World of Curiosities.
My review of The Grey Wolf.
Some Monday Readings
Your phone is a fake house – Adam Aleksic at The Etymology Nerd.
Our Days Are Short – Terry Whalin at the Writing Life.
An Autumn View Over London from Westminster Cathedral – A London Inheritance.
How to Ask Timeless Questions – Joseph Epstein at The Free Press.
Thoughts on Ethan Frome – Michael Connolly at The Imaginative Conservative.